Topic 5c Circular Economy, Zero-waste and Innovation

Related UN-SDGs

Who we are

Pauline Deutz

University of Hull, Hull, United Kingdom

p.deutz@hull.ac.uk

Roberta Salomone

Department of Economics, University of Messina, Messina, Italy

roberta.salomone@unime.it

Mohd Helmi Ali

Graduate School of Business, National University of Malaysia (UKM). mohdhelmiali@ukm.edu.my

Andrea Cecchin

HowGood, New York, USA. andrea@howgood.com


Goals and Objectives

Circular economy (CE) research has taken off exponentially in the last years, with concerted policy efforts from the European Union and other organizations. Aiming at an economic system wherein products are designed to maximise the value extracted from resources, much attention is being paid to how organisations (primarily, but not only, private companies) can devise and develop circular business models (Santa Maria et al., 2021). Research is also considering how companies can work in conjunction with the place they are based (Delgadillo, 2021) and range of stakeholder perspectives involved (Rincón-Moreno et al., 2022). However, the development of a CE could contribute to a social transformation. A tension is emerging between policy views of the CE as a form of Sustainable (economic) Development, and approaches to circularity, such as repair, refurbishment, which can be driven by organisations with a social rather than profit-driven orientation (Lekan et al., 2021). Whether the context is public, private or third sector, there is a need to assess, rather than assume, whether a given activity is environmentally and/or socially sustainable, aside from the potentially more apparent economic advantages (Roos Lindgreen et al., 2020).

This session aims to contribute to the understanding of the sustainability impact of CE practices and the different routes to innovation that may be required, also exploring theoretical and pragmatic implications related to the Sustainable Development Goals 9 (Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure) and 12 (Responsible Consumption and Production). More critical attention is needed to examine the environmental, social, and economic impact of CE practices, and how those impacts may be context and/or scale dependent.

References

  • Earlier versions of papers cited herein have all been presented at ISDRS conferences. We are happy that there are too many to possibly include them all. For more information see Track 5c page on the ISDRS website.
  • Delgadillo, E., Reyes, T. & Baumgartner, R. 2021. Towards Territorial Product-service Systems: A Framework Linking Resources, Networks and Value Creation. Sustainable Production and Consumption. 28 1297-1313. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2021.08.003
  • Lekan, M., Jonas, A. E.G. & Deutz, P. 2021. Circularity as Alterity? Untangling Circuits of Value in the Social Enterprise–Led Local Development of the Circular Economy. Economic Geography, 97 (3) 257-283.  https://doi.org/10.1080/00130095.2021.1931109
  • Rincón-Moreno, J., Ormazábal M., & Jaca, C., 2022. Stakeholder Perspectives in Transitioning to a Local Circular Economy: a Case Study in Spain. Circular Economy and Sustainability 2, 693–711 https://doi.org/10.1007/s43615-021-00098-x
  • Roos Lindgreen, E., Salomone, R., & Reyes, T. 2020.  A Critical Review of Academic Approaches, Methods and Tools to Assess Circular Economy at the Micro Level.  Sustainability 12 4973.  https://doi.org/10.3390/su12124973
  • Santa-Maria, T., Vermeulen, W. J. V., & Baumgartner, R. J. 2021. How do incumbent firms innovate their business models for the circular economy? Identifying micro-foundations of dynamic capabilities. Business Strategy and the Environment. pp. 1–28. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.2956

Contributions shedding light on the following area are welcome:

  • policy efforts to engender CE-practices, especially in emerging and developing economies;
  • CE practices and comparative case studies that elucidate various dimensions, business types, 9R strategy implemented and challenges to be faced;
  • start-ups and ‘green’ businesses adjusted to CE principles;
  • Circular Business Models and their implementation
  • relationship between the circular economy and degrowth
  • role of the Sharing Economy;
  • role of the Circular Bioeconomy;
  • consumer perspectives and stakeholder’s perceptions and roles in CE;
  • role of industrial symbiosis, networks in resource management, and zero waste programs and projects;
  • role of Industrial Ecology methods and tools (e.g. material flow analysis, input-output analysis, life cycle assessment) to achieving a CE;
  • quantification of the specific environmental, economic and social impacts of CE;
  • CE metrics and performance indicators;
  • drivers of innovation in resource management, resource security, and resource efficiency;
  • initiation and resilience of CE practices in a rapidly changing context;
  • CE in cities;
  • relationships between native culture’s thought and CE principles.

Other CE-related contributions can also be explored.

Length and content of the proposed abstract to the track

Each proposed abstract (in connection to one of the areas pointed out above), within 300 and 500 words (including everything):

  1. shall be best organized (without headlines) along usual structures (e.g. intro/method/findings or results/ discussion/conclusions)
  2. does not need to, but can include references
  3. shall provide in a final section
  4. a. to which SDG(s) and SDG-target(s) their proposed abstract especially relate to (e.g. “SDG+Target: 14.1.”).
  5. b. a brief indication how the proposed contribution relates to the topic of the Conference “Sustainability and Beyond“

News

A special issue of the journal Circular Economy and Sustainability based on the Budapest conference was published in 2022. The contents are: Deutz, Cecchin and Salomone Circular Economy and Sustainability: View from the ISDRS 2020 Conference

Henriques, Azevedo, Dias, Estrela, Ascenço,, Vladimirova and Miller Implementing Industrial Symbiosis Incentives: an Applied Assessment Framework for Risk Mitigation

Rincón-Moreno, Ormazábal and Jaca Stakeholder Perspectives in Transitioning to a Local Circular Economy: a Case Study in Spain

Prieto-Sandoval, Mejia-Villa, Jaca and Ormazabal, The Case of an Agricultural Crop Business Association in Navarra as Circular Economy Intermediary

Walker, Opferkuch, Roos Lindgreen, Raggi, Simboli, Vermeulen, Caeiro, Salomone    What Is the Relation between Circular Economy and Sustainability? Answers from Frontrunner Companies Engaged with Circular Economy Practices

Klein, Ramos and Deutz Advancing the Circular Economy in Public Sector Organisations: Employees’ Perspectives on Practices

Newsholme, Deutz, Affolderbach and Baumgartner Negotiating Stakeholder Relationships in a Regional Circular Economy: Discourse Analysis of Multi-scalar Policies and Company Statements from the North of England

ISDRS Team visits USA April 2019 to deliver thought provoking discussions on the Circular Economy and the UN Sustainable Development Goals: READ MORE 

Past Conference

Kuala Lumpur, 2023

Track chair: Simon Lockrey, Associate Professor, RMIT, Australia.

Design for Sustainability - grew to 22 papers presented over 5 sessions at ISDRS Malaysia 2023. So that's great news! Topics were wide and varied, covering design of products, textiles, infrastructure, packaging, services, strategy, architecture, participatory outcomes, and focusing on topics such as consumer perceptions, play, food waste, climate change, bio renewal, regional development, and responsibility. All in all, the role of design was paramount and palpable in sustainability causes across these terrific papers, presented from scholars from the Asia-Pacific, Europe, South America, China, and beyond.

ISDRS 2021

Track chair: Klara Tóthné Szita  

Sustainable design of a trigger sprayer suitable to e-commerce market. A case study of design for material reduction, disassembling and recycling 

Lucia Pietroni, Jacopo Mascitti, Daniele Galloppo 

The presentation was showed by Jacopo and Daniel. They prepared also a full paper. 

They investigated the environmental impact of the material reduction, disassembling and recycling with applying LCA method.  it was a typical case study of product design following the environmental and economic aspect. 

I support the publication at journal. 

Design strategies in times of pandemic – a case study of how Covid-19 is visualized in the Nordic countries Sweden, Norway, Finland, Denmark and Island 

Karina Goransson, Anna- Sara Fagerholm 

The problem was very interesting approach of social innovation. Both of authors spoken. The presentation based on the content and infographic analysis were used during the pandemic. They applied comparative analysis of posters, between Nordic countries’ communication materials. The authors have not showed that taking epidemic related infographics seriously reduced covid 19 infections, although it could have strength the paper.  

After the presentation there was interesting discussion about papers and general questions of responsible sustainable production and consumption (SDG’12), why important the ecodesign aspect in the product development. We have spoken about the desing orienting scenarios of the SusHouse project,– it was elaborated twenty years age, and had prepared sustainable strategies towards sustainable household 2050. It is actual today, - how possible decrease the environmental load on based of factor 20, and the 3 pillars of sustainability, while there also measured the consumer attitude, and used future study tools backcasting and future workshop and design orienting scenario methods..  

Messina, Italy, 2018

Chairs: Astrid Skjerven, Marzia Traverso

The topic met great interest from the conference participants, which was testified by the necessity to create 3 different track sessions to give room to all speakers. There were 13 presentations in total. The contributions covered different sector such as automotive, fashion and building. Even if the focus was sustainability the most of presentations were about environmental pillar of sustainability, only a couple of them include the life cycle costing (and consequently the economic pillar). The contributions were different qualitatively from a more superficial qualitative approach to a quantitative and scientific one. Several reflected the gap between the attitudes of stakeholders and the implementation of eco-friendly solutions. Most used quantitative methods and statistics. Some tended to compare incongruent parameters. Provided further development some of them might become useful tools in building and rebuilding processes. By the way, the importance of this session is very high as well as the necessity to expand to all three pillars of sustainability.

Projects

This track has been closely associated with the H2020 project ‘Cresting’. Outputs including policy briefings and a list of academic publications to date are available from the project website

Publications

Innovative research on the circular economy presented at 2019 ISDRS conference is published in leading academic journals

 

Three papers from the CRESTING project were recently published in Resources, Conservation & Recycling and in the Journal of Cleaner Production. All three papers were based on research presented at the 2019 ISDRS conference in Najing, China.


The first paper is titled “How circular is your tyre: Experiences with extended producer responsibility from a circular economy perspective” (open access) and was published in the Journal of Cleaner Production. It examines the governance and sustainability outcomes of the waste management system for end of life tyres in the Netherlands, leading to key insights and recommendations for the sector.


The second paper is entitled “The Circular Economy and Cascading: Towards a Framework” (open access) and was published in the journal Resources Conservation & Recycling X. It integrates cascading and circular economy practices leading to a new theoretical framework that considers the necessities and complicities of circular economy governance.


The third paper is entitled “A typology of circular economy discourses: Navigating the diverse visions of a contested paradigm” (open access) and was published in the journal Resources Conservation & Recycling. It builds the first typology of circularity discourses to date by identifying 72 different CE-related concepts from the Global North and South (such as Gandhian and steady-state economics, buen vivir, doughnut economics and degrowth) and conceptually classifying them based on to their position on fundamental socio-ecological issues.


The presentation of the preliminary results of all three studies in the 2019 ISDRS conference allowed for constructive feedback and helped authors improve the quality and depth of their analysis. The young authors also participated in the ISDRS PhD day, where they received further comments and suggestions on how to improve their papers. The resulting publications are at the forefront of research on the circular economy, showing the usefulness of the ISDRS conferences and network for young academics seeking to publish their results, kickstart their careers and, most importantly, contribute to leading academic debates with fresh new ideas.


Knowledge Resources


State of the Art:

Getting beyond the messy conceptualization of CE

In a just published article in Resources, Conservation and Recycling, we discuss and synthesize the diverse inputs from a range of academic disciplines into the discourses. We analysed 69 scientific articles that explicitly referred to a waste hierarchy in terms of a 3R, 4R or more. Read more

Recommended Sources

The top useful sources are the following:

1) Useful courses available at the UN SDG Academy; see for example "Globalization: past and future".

2) SDG Academy see for example Natural resources for sustainable development’ 

3) Circular Economy accord to the Ellen MacArthur Foundation

4) ISDRS based book: International Perspectives on Industrial Ecology


Routledge & Earthscans' Sustainability Hub

Find useful essays, free books and articles, case studies and more at our partner's website


Recommended Sources:

The top useful sources are the following:

1) Useful courses available at the UN SDG Academy; see for example "Globalization: past and future".

2) SDG Academy see for example Natural resources for sustainable development’ 

3) Circular Economy accord to the Ellen MacArthur Foundation

4) ISDRS based book: International Perspectives on Industrial Ecology